When I eat, I flip on the TV or open my phone. I fly into my head, away from my belly. The screens take me away from what I am putting in my mouth. Not being mindful of my eating has packed on the pounds because I don’t settle down to taste my food until the second helping. I am missing out on one of the best pleasures my body and the ground, the sun, the air can offer.
As I edge towards my death, I wonder why I am denying myself. Someday this body, these taste buds, this stomach will be buried. And even though I believe in the resurrection of the body, she won’t be the same as this one. I won’t be able to eat my favorite salad—grapes, lettuce, Bolthouse honey mustard dressing, spinach, olives, almonds, feta, tomatoes. I won’t feel how refreshing it is to put down my empty bowl and do the next thing.
Christians have made eating a sacrament, central to their worship, so why not slow down, give thanks for the people, the ground, the sunlight, the rain, that has made this food? Why not put the phone away, take a bite, set the fork down, and taste what’s inside my mouth? Why not listen to what scientists say about how it takes twenty minutes to feel satisfied with our meal? I am so fragmented, I’m going to practice settling down to enjoy this great good pleasure. As the Psalmist says, “Oh taste and see that the Lord is good.”
I’m Katie Andraski and that’s my perspective.
If you’d like to hear me read this, click on the WNIJ Perspectives page here.
Eating has been fraught for me ever since I was a little girl. I remember taking Carnation Instant Breakfast as my lunch and mixing it with a small carton of milk, to help me lose weight. Having matured when I was ten, I was heavy. My body curved like the hills that rolled through the upstate New York countryside. I was too big for my thirteen hand pony, so we bought a fifteen hand horse that was better suited. Those days the rail thin model Twiggy, shaped more like a boy than a woman, shifted the emphasis of womanly beauty away from the curvy ideal of Marilyn Monroe. In movies during that time only women whose hip bones cradled a taught belly were found worthy of love.
So I obsessed about losing weight. I tried to eat small meals, but every time I said I was going to go on a diet my dad would bring home cookies or donuts or I’d stuff myself to get ready for the upcoming fast. So much denial just made food look better. I was teased in high school for hairy legs and being overweight, though looking back, I’d consider the weight I maintained as a girl as quite right. My thighs, my belly pushed against my jeans. My body took up too much space in the world. I wanted to be beautiful like the glancing light on trees, leaves flipped up to the wind, but I was not. Often I said I was sorry. Add to that monthly cycles that made my belly ached and I was not at peace with my body. When my mother bought me beautiful clothes for Christmas I was not comfortable trying them on for my aunts to admire. (They told me later they hated how my brother and I got all this stuff at Christmas. I don’t blame them though envy sucks.)
I began to make peace when I dumped into my twenties and fell in love with a few men. The farmer teased many poems and part of a novel out of me and the poet taught me how to lean up against trees, feeling kisses and ticks crawling up my back. He loved me back. I liked myself as a woman. I liked using my charm. I joined Weight Watchers during that time and they taught me how to eat, and showed me all the good things I could eat. I felt happier with boundaries around food.
This was a version that encouraged a person to drink two servings of milk a day, five ounces of fish a week, a serving of liver, which I avoided, so many ounces of protein, five fruits and vegetables, two servings of bread. I lost a quarter, a half pound a week, but I found I was happier. There were so many good things to eat. When I returned to school I’d lost 15 pounds and people thought I was in love. (I was.)
I didn’t realize that the whole beauty culture was a way to keep women, who were exerting their rights, under control , by keeping them hungry all the time. Naomi Wolf in The Beauty Myth says, “A culture fixated in female thinness is not an obsession about female beauty but an obsession about female obedience. Dieting is the most potent political sedative in women’s history; a quietly mad population is a tractable one.”
My mother who was a powerful woman, drank Metracal to try to take weight off. She bought the first Weight Watchers book but disapproved with how gaunt a friend looked who’d tried it. She didn’t eat much, but what she did eat was high in calories. I recall her eating many cream cheese and olive sandwiches and sparse suppers. As a teenager I fat shamed her, but now my body looks about like hers. These things come back to haunt you. When her cancer had devoured her round, rumpy curves, she said one good thing was she was finally thin, after all these years. Her crossed hands rested in that hollow between her hipbones in the casket.
Marrying Bruce helped me make even deeper peace with with my rumpy curves because he loved them. His hands blessed them. The pill also helped because it stopped the debilitating monthly pain I’d begun to feel. I went back to Weight Watchers to please him. For the first time I could fit into size 12 pants. But that soon slipped away, my jeans growing to a tight size 16. I read how it’s pretty hopeless to lose weight because our bodies work against us. I ate whatever I wanted, when I wanted. It was good to stop feeling guilty about what I put in my mouth. Even St. Paul says we are so free we can eat anything we want. “All things are lawful. All things are not expedient.”
Years later, I saw how fat I looked on my horse in the above picture and decided to rejoin Weight Watchers. This time I was successful in losing forty pounds, even though I was in my fifties and menopausal. I learned to stop eating when I was satisfied. I could eat anything in moderation. I swore I’d not go back there again. But I gained ten pounds and went on tamoxifen for pre breast cancer. Since that makes a person gain weight, I continued to go to meetings hoping to maintain where I was.
But lately I have felt abandoned by the program. Zero point foods don’t make sense to me. Those foods have calories and nutritional value. It’s obvious that the program is pushing us towards eating fruits, vegetables, chicken, fish, beans, tofu. Weight Watchers now feels more like a restrictive diet, instead of look at what you can eat. I’ve been successful in keeping my weight steady until Christmas when people gave us candy for Christmas, and my indulgence, broke any self discipline I had, and I gained close to ten pounds. Weight Watchers wasn’t working for me any longer.
This winter the nerve pain in my leg felt like someone laid a piece of burning kindling on the outside of my thigh. It woke me. My leg tingled when I was lying down and when I was standing. Walking eased it. The docs think it’s meralgia paresthetica what I call the fat lady syndrome. Obese and pregnant women get it because their fat pushes against the nerve that runs down the outside of the thigh. One of the treatments is to lose weight. Since Weight Watchers wasn’t working, I decided to try Noom, a weight loss program advertised on NPR and Facebook.
It is everything I have wished Weight Watchers could be because it focuses on food and the science of eating. The app has cute articles that talk about how we can stop ourselves from over eating and why it is that once we start losing weight it can be difficult to continue because our hormones and environment work against us. But instead of leaving us helpless, they offer tools like strength training, and even indulging ourselves to compensate for this. We have a goals coach and a group coach that helps us stay accountable to setting goals that might help us change our habits. We weigh in daily, which I have found interesting because I can see how my calorie intake affects my weight. I see how it takes a few days for dietary indiscretions to catch up. For the first time in years, I am consistently losing weight simply by counting calories and by listening to how full I feel. I am motivated to make better choices when I eat out. Noom has a green, yellow, red scale where they show whether you are foods that are dense nutritionally but easy on calories. Mostly I’m working on savoring my food, giving this pleasure the attention it deserves.
Here is a link if you are interested in checking it out. This is an affiliate link, so do get paid if you join the program past the trial. https://friends.noom.com/YUo5WjU3ODdI
Even clouds aren’t afraid to be full and round and rumpy, heavy with rain.
Speaking of food, we’ve been aware of how consistent rain since March has made it difficult for farmers to plant their crops. I have worried about our food supply. In Nebraska where there was devastating flooding, and farmers have been told not to bother planting. They lost a million beef cattle. Our neighbor just finished planting over a thousand acres with help from neighbors. They’d get dry days and get into the fields. Since we’ve had warm days, the corn has shot up from baby plants to knee high by fourth of July. Some is even hip high. There are still empty fields growing weeds, but I am hopeful when I see the corn and beans drawn towards the light and sky.
If you’d like to be sure to see my blog posts when they are posted, click here.
Katie, I’m fat now at age 62, aspiring to be thin again if only in the Resurrection.
I was a chubby kid in junior high and mostly in shape from high school through college, marriage, early fatherhood, and into my mid thirties. I got fat then by stress-eating and lack of exercise. Then, I lost the weight again for a time, but now I am a hundred pounds over my ideal of 160, which I know I’ll never see again unless, like your mother, cancer sinks its ugly teeth into me. I hope I have her sense of humor if that day ever comes! I would like to lose fifty pounds though without having to be sick to do it.
Karen and I have been thin and fat together. There’s some consolation in that, I guess. We did love how our bodies better fused in our embracing when we were both thin, but a more well-rounded embracing has its own joyous charms, as well. But, ah who the hell cares? Nothing is what it was when compared to our youths, but we are both so very grateful that we still have one another to hold on to and for more ways than mere lovemaking!
You write above that:
“Someday this body, these taste buds, this stomach will be buried. And even though I believe in the resurrection of the body, she won’t be the same as this one. I won’t be able to eat my favorite salad—grapes, lettuce, Bolthouse honey mustard dressing, spinach, olives, almonds, feta, tomatoes. I won’t feel how refreshing it is to put down my empty bowl and do the next thing.“
Don’t you think that there will be food and productive labor in the Hereafter? I do. The Revelation describes such, doesn’t it? No sex though, it seems . . . but something far better that we cannot now even imagine, but in our most splendid and holiest joys we do sense it, don’t we?
Oh yes I do think there will be food and productive labor in the resurrection. But this particular body won’t make it I don’t think. She will be transformed like Jesus’ body was. I hear you on holding onto each other in many ways.
As far as weight loss I go back and forth. I’m trying this program which is very helpful, but there are weeks I wonder if it’s worth it or if I”m capable of doing it. But the app is very positive and takes a psychological approach that is light hearted and practical. If you want to drop that 50 lbs you might try it and see…I too have been the chubby person my whole life.
At any rate, thanks for sharing so honestly. Deep peace be with you and Karen
I just this morning signed on with Noom, Katie, mainly because you mentioned it in your post. You ought to see if you can get the $20 they offer for recruiting me. I do like Noom’s quirky personality and psychology-based approach. Karen & I are on WW, but I’m gonna drop my ineffectual membership there. If I succeed with Noom, Karen will most likely join us.
By the way, when I closed my comment above with, “Hallelujah,” i thought later that I should have included this cover that I love of Leonard Cohen’s classic.
Here’s looking forward to that Day when all our “Hallelujah”s are neither cold nor broken. But no matter how we sing it while we suffer the here and now, He IS worthy of all praise!
I hope you’re enjoying Noom. I’m finding trying to do mindful eating is harder than I thought it would be. I know my weight is down in general but it’s a challenge. They have a lot of great ideas with regards to living life more healthfully. I’m appreciating how they say to write down the things you do accomplish in a day instead of a to do list and I appreciate the nudge to turn off social media early in the evening.
“I’m your huckleberry!”
Down 10 pounds in just two weeks, even with a slip or two, Noomin’ every day, and back to walking after a three year hiatus. I’m challenging my inner naysayer, “Johnny Ringo,” to play for blood now, a real fight to the death that I’ve come to WIN! ?
That’s fabulous! Congratulations! Men do lose faster than women though. But I’ve not worked super hard at it either, as in I’m not increasing exercise. Good for you on challenging your inner naysayer. I keep saying I can do this…Love this program as well…I like that it also talks about other aspects of our lives. I hope you get Karen to join.
Karen is doing well with WW again, Katie. She’ll probably stick with that, but it’s good that we’re doing this thing together just the same. What I love about Noom is the psychology, which I’m finding to be very practical and effective for me. Our church will soon be hosting “Celebrate Recovery” on Friday nights starting in September if all goes as planned. Our music minister’s son is a recovering drug addict. He’s going to help lead the group for substance abuse. I’m an in-recovery food addict, and I’d like to help lead that group. I think that using Noom could help us all, and I plan to recommend it. Of course, God and His Word will be the foundation for everything, but I’ve found that using Noom is helping me spiritually, as well. I know that I’m only beginning my third week, but suffice it to say, as Noom always gets us to do, “I BELIEVE!”